Essential reading for retailers and suppliers in the home improvement market

Scotts contests Which? compost trial

Published: 24 February 2010
Gardencare manufacturer claims testers did not follow pack instructions, as Which? Gardening issues a 'Don't Buy' warning on Miracle-Gro Moisture Control Compost.
Scotts contests Which? compost trial
The Scotts Miracle-Gro Company has hit back after one of its leading products was branded a 'Don't Buy' compost in Which? Gardening's latest report on container compost.

The manufacturer is adamant that the product was not used according to the instructions provided and that additional nutrients added at the time of potting affected the compost's performance.

The trial, which was published in the March issue, saw experts plant 936 impatiens and 312 seed potatoes in 624 containers last spring to test the 26 different brands of compost on test.

Testers then assessed the impatiens for flowering between June and October, while the potatoes were harvested in August and their yield and quality recorded.

Miracle-Gro Moisture Control Compost scored just 31% and was dubbed a 'Don't Buy' compost. Which? Gardening said of the product: "This compost received the lowest score. The impatiens preformed poorly from the start - they showed signs of nutrient deficiency within the first few weeks and were less vigorous than impatiens in the other composts on test. We harvested 0.5kg fewer potatoes on average from this compost than from our Best Buys. Compost quality also varied from bag to bag."

However, Scotts contests this result and argues that the addition of a slow-release fertiliser, which was incorporated into each pot of compost at the start of the trial, affected the nutrient balance in the soil.

A spokesperson for the company said: "Miracle-Gro Moisture Control Compost was not used in the trial according to the instructions on the label. The Which? Gardening report indicates that further nutrients were added to the compost (and all the others) at the time of potting, dangerously increasing the nutrient levels of this already rich compost."

They added: "Another indicator that the care regime recommended may not have been followed is that Scotts' price fighting brand, Murphy Multi Purpose Compost, outperformed most other products in the trial - even Miracle-Gro Moisture Control Compost. This has not happened before in any of Scotts trials."

Scotts explained that it had carried out "hundreds" of growing trials, which showed the Moisture Control Compost to offer "superior performance to almost all other composts on the market" and that it had received letters of praise from consumers.

Scotts concluded: "The company will be speaking to Which? Gardening to clarify what went wrong and to explore the validity of testing composts by adding further nutrients at the time of potting."

Vital Earth Tub and Basket Compost and New Horizon Multi-Purpose Compost topped the bill in the Which? trial, scoring 83% and 82% respectively.


Published prior to March 2014
By suzanne
I have had trouble with bags of grow more I bought
growing horrible mould over the surface brown and discusting I complained to The Gardencentre told it was liky it was spres from the atmospere but no other dirt had grown it Then Growmore said it was because of reduced peat in their soilit wont effect the growing Well it has I havnt had any of my seeds grow and discusted with their attitude
Published prior to March 2014
By Rebecca Leach - Which? Gardening
The above story is not completely accurate.

A slow release fertiliser was added to the composts tested at the point of planting as this is considered good practice is something Which? Gardening advises. However, in the case of Miracle Gro Moisture Control Compost, the compost did not have any additional fertiliser added as it clearly states on the packaging that this is not necessary.

All the plants in the trial were checked daily and watered as required by hand.

Which? Gardening has been using this same methodology for many years. Buying compost from four different regions of the country and trialling it over the summer period is, in Which?'s opinion, the best way to compare the performance of growing media.

(Your email address will not be published)
2 + 6 =  
Already Registered?
Sign In
Not Yet Registered?
Printable View E-mail Bookmark

Latest reader comments

re: Latest update on Green Homes Grant and implications for homeowners and landlords

John Hart
After applying for a green homes how long will it take for a decision? thanks...

re: SX Rainproof Exterior Caulk

I need the exterior sx rain resistant caulk! Can't get it anywhere so please help! How can I order it? Need it yesterday...

re: BCT can replicate any material in a ceramic tile

Christina Tiritanou
Not sure if you can help as I require a tile which has the measurements of 6”x 6”? Thank you....

re: Latest update on Green Homes Grant and implications for homeowners and landlords

colin thompson
SarahVery clear and helpful information.Thanks...

Most read stories