Essential reading for retailers and suppliers in the home improvement market

B&Q best for compost says Which? trial

Published: 8 January 2010
B&Q's own brand composts topped the tables in Which?'s research into the bet composts on the market, but Homebase came bottom of the leader board.
B&Q best for compost says Which? trial
The trial carried out throughout 2009, tested 24 composts. Each compost was purchased four times from different areas of the country to allow for variation between batches. Two trials were conducted, one to test multipurpose and john Innes composts, and one for composts specifically recommended for sowing seeds or growing on young plants.

The seed sowing trial was divided into two strands, an easy-to-grow basil and a tricky petunia. Experts at an independent site sowed 25 basil seeds into 12 pots of each compost. The number of germinated seeds and quality of resulting seedlings was recorded. The same test was carried out with the Petunias.

The three Best Buys in this test were B&Q multipurpose compost, B&Q sowing and cutting compost and New Horizon peat-free grow bag.

The B&Q multipurpose compost was consistently the best performing compost on test. It contains 63% peat, less than ever before, and costs £3.98 for a 70-litre bag making it the cheapest on test as well.

The test for growing on new plants used antirrhinum plugs, because they are sensitive to high nutrient levels, and cabbage plugs because they quickly show nutrient deficiencies. The size and quality of the plants were assessed after six weeks.

Again, B&Q took first and second with its multipurpose compost and John Innes No 2 compost respectively. Westland West+ multipurpose was also named an Best Buy.

The best peat-free composts on test were Westland West+ peat free multipurpose compost and the New Horizon peat-free grow bag

Homebase's multipurpose peat-free compost was named Don't Buy in both tests.


Published prior to March 2014
By Tamsin
We have used this compost for several years and until now have found it reliable. This year the compost is covered in a layer of mould and the seedlings are really poor. Can anyone explain this?
Published prior to March 2014
By Jane Oliphant, consultant editor, DIY Week
Thank you for your comment on this story. Please note that it was published in January 2010, and so is now out of date - which explains why your information is different.
Published prior to March 2014
By Mr S White
Have the new Which magazine in front of me. No1 was SylvaGrow, joint No2 Levingtons multi purpose waterlock system, Hpmebase, Thompson & Morgan, Waitrose, and Westland. No mention of B&Q.
Published prior to March 2014
By Ray Taylor
Hi I bought a bag of the above with the aim of sowing my seed in a nice easy to handle medium. I have used Levingtons for a good few years but this compost makes it almost impossible to sow small seeds due to its make up I am 80 years old but I can tell you I wont be buying the same compost again. I am not blaming B&Q but would you let the suppliers know that this product falls far below what it used to be
Published prior to March 2014
By brandon
this compost is great quality, is very well priced,great for all jobs and is very well draining!
Published prior to March 2014
By wb nattress
as a commercial grower i have used this compost for at least 10 yrs and found it to be a very good all round growing medium . this year they have reduced the size from 70 ltr to 60 but as a pensioner i make good use of my 10% discount on a wednesday
Published prior to March 2014
By P Brown
very course, full of twigs and honey fungus awful quality
Published prior to March 2014
By Gill
Bought three bags of this on offer last year and it was the worse I have ever bought. Full of twigs and rubbish. The plants I repotted will need redoing because of its poor quality. I have thrown the rest onto the garden to dig in,
Published prior to March 2014
By william nattress
b and q compost has now shrunk from 70 ltr to 60 ltr per bag at the same price but its water retaining properties has diminished so its not the good buy it was
Published prior to March 2014
By tony
not according to my which gardening magazine. It was only the b&q seed compost!!

(Your email address will not be published)
Already Registered?
Sign In
Not Yet Registered?
Printable View E-mail Bookmark

What do you think?

With a hung parliament, unpopular Conservative/DUP alliance, and maybe even another vote on the cards - what is your biggest worry after the fall-out of the election?

Latest reader comments

re: Bunnings reveals locations of the three further UK pilot stores

Ken Walker
If they live upto what is in Australia, then there's no worries. Fantastic should give the likes b and q and homebase a run for their ...

re: B&Q retail director makes move to Bunnings

bq bob
To pay the 2% NLW increase this year BQ "reviewed" the location allowance paid to staff then in my store reduced it by 25p per hour! The ...

re: Bunnings reveals locations of the three further UK pilot stores

Barbara New
I am a loyal customer to Homebase Sevenoaks and i am watching the store sink since you have taken it over. The garden section has never ...

re: B&Q retail director makes move to Bunnings

Very true leaving en masse. Says something when the big boys start abandoning ship. Staff down customers down makes you wonder what's going ...

re: B&Q invites suppliers to pitch at Innovation Open Day

Mike A ..
Having been involved in many new product innovations and acheived over $1bn at retail with them, the large format stores are the last place ...